Immerse yourself in the vibrant world of Jamaican culture with Jamaicanopoly, a unique twist on the classic Monopoly board Click Here for more information
This includes former Speaker of the House John Bercow who criticised the system for protecting an MP who chooses to lie to the country and punishing any member of parliament “with the guts to tell the truth”. He has since argued for a change to the Commons rules that bar MPs from calling each other liars, arguing that these rules were meant for a time when MPs “sought conscientiously to tell the truth and would quickly apologise and correct the record if they inadvertently misled the house”, something this current government refuses to do.
This rule is among a variety of strange regulations still in place in the House of Commons. For example, MPs must refer to each other as the “honourable member”, applause is forbidden and members cannot call each other a coward, hypocrite, guttersnipe or pipsqueak and many other strange names from a bygone era. Archaic rules like these are a consequence of our long unchanged democracy. We still have an entirely unelected second chamber of Parliament, a rarity around the world, many of whose members inherited their position in the House of Lords. Furthermore, membership of this House is often doled out in return for political favours. This is not surprising in a country that still has an unelected head of state. Even the democratically elected House of Commons has its own issues. The ‘first past the post’ system used to allocate seats, continuously leads to a disproportionate number of Labour and Conservative MPs, allowing the Conservative party to make up 56% of the house despite getting only 43% of the nation’s votes. Results like these are why many in British politics are seeking proportional representation to decide how our elections are won.
Dawn Butler’s actions highlight the urgent need for reform in British democracy.
It is vital that politicians are able to call each other out on any lies and correct the record for the public. The fact that the Labour MP was punished for this only accentuates the problem and reveals another flaw in our problematic democracy. The government has relied on being able to lie to and mislead the public on a regular basis, without facing any consequences, throughout this pandemic and as a result, we have had one of the worst pandemic responses in the world.